As an Amazon Associate, The Gem Tray earns from qualifying purchases. Amazon links on this page are paid links; buying through them costs you nothing extra.

Are lab emeralds real emeralds?

A lab-created emerald is the same mineral as a mined one: coloured green by chromium or vanadium, hardness 7.5 to 8, sold as lab-created emerald. The big difference is treatment: “well over 90% of the emeralds in commerce have been treated to minimize the appearance of the ” (International Gem Society), usually with oil. Both are softer than sapphire (9). In the US, “lab-created emerald” must have essentially the same properties as emerald, “simulated emerald” is an imitation, and sellers may not call a lab stone “real”, “genuine” or “natural” (16 CFR 23.25 and 23.27).

Illustration: are lab emeralds real emeralds?
Illustration (AI render) of this kind of piece, not a photo of any listing.

Same mineral, different origin

Emerald is beryl, Be3Al2Si6O18, coloured green by chromium or sometimes vanadium. Lab emerald is grown from a solution by flux or hydrothermal methods (see how lab emeralds are made); a gemmologist tells it apart by its inclusions, and, if needed, , not by a simple home test.

Treatment and oiling

The International Gem Society says well over 90% of the emeralds in commerce have been treated to minimise the look of their inclusions, with oiling the standard industry practice; non-standard treatments use green-coloured oils and hardened, epoxy-like resins. Under US rules, a treatment that is not permanent or needs special care must be disclosed (16 CFR 23.24).

Durability

At 7.5 to 8 on the scale, emerald, lab or mined, is softer than ruby or sapphire (9), and GIA notes that emeralds are softer than diamonds. In rings and tennis bracelets, bezel or other protective settings are the safer choice.

Reading the listing

Under 16 CFR 23.25, an unqualified “emerald” must be a mined emerald; a lab-made one must be called “laboratory-grown”, “laboratory-created” or “[manufacturer name]-created” emerald, and only if it has essentially the same optical, physical and chemical properties as emerald; anything that only looks like emerald must be called “imitation” or “simulated”. Sellers may not call a lab-made stone “real”, “genuine” or “natural” (16 CFR 23.27). “Emerald green” names a colour; a listing that uses it without one of those terms has not told you what the stone is.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do lab emeralds have inclusions?

Yes, but different ones: flux stones may contain flux, platinum crystals and crystals (International Gem Society), and hydrothermal stones can show colour zoning and cone-shaped nailhead (Gems & Gemology, 1997).

Is green glass sold as lab emerald?

A listing should say “lab-created emerald” only if the stone is beryl, and “simulated” or “imitation” if it is not (16 CFR 23.25). A gemmologist can check with a : flux emerald reads about 1.560 to 1.566 and hydrothermal emerald about 1.566 to 1.576 (International Gem Society).

Sources

Keep reading

Amazon links are affiliate links (tag thegemtray-20): buying through them costs you nothing extra and supports the site. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.