How are lab-grown emeralds made?
Lab emerald is grown from a solution, by flux or hydrothermal methods (GIA), not by flame fusion. , the mineral of emerald, is an incongruent melting material: it does not melt into a liquid of its own composition, so the fast melt methods used for ruby and sapphire have not been used for it (US patent 4,218,282). Flux growth crystallises emerald from a molten flux, and GIA says crystal growth can take up to a year. Hydrothermal growth deposits it from a hot, pressurised water solution; Union Carbide’s patent, first filed in 1964, reports an average growth of 0.1 mm a day along a crystal edge. Both are slow and costly, which is why lab emerald costs more per carat than lab sapphire.
Why emerald is not made in a flame
Emerald is beryl, Be3Al2Si6O18, coloured green by chromium or sometimes vanadium. A 1980 US patent notes that because beryl is an incongruent melting material, efficient melt-growth methods such as Czochralski pulling had not been used for it. So commercial lab emerald is grown from a solution, and it arrived decades after flame-fusion ruby.
Flux growth
The ingredients are dissolved in a molten flux, and emerald crystallises out. GIA says growing a gem by the flux method requires patience and significant investment, that crystal growth can take up to a year, and that the equipment is very expensive. Richard Nacken grew flux emeralds in Germany from 1923 to 1925 (Gems & Gemology, 2016), and Pierre Gilson’s flux emeralds have been on the market since 1964.
Hydrothermal growth
Nutrients dissolve in a water solution under heat and pressure, and crystals form as it cools (GIA); hydrothermal emerald for jewellery appeared in 1960. Union Carbide’s patent, with a 1964 priority date, grows beryl on a at about 425 to 800 C and 7,000 to 30,000 psi in an alkaline fluoride solution, and reports an average growth of 0.1 mm a day along a crystal edge. Union Carbide’s Linde division made hydrothermal emeralds from 1965 to 1970, and Tairus is now the largest producer of hydrothermal emerald.
How a lab tells them apart
Flux emerald typically has a lower and specific gravity than natural emerald (refractive index about 1.560 to 1.566, specific gravity 2.65 to 2.67) and may contain flux, platinum crystals and crystals (International Gem Society). Hydrothermal emerald can show growth and colour zoning and cone-shaped voids called nailhead , and stones grown in a chlorine-bearing solution show chlorine-related features in the (Gems & Gemology, 1997).
History
French scientists grew emerald crystals about 1 mm across from fluxes in 1888 and 1890; Richard Nacken grew flux emeralds in Germany from 1923 to 1925; IG Farben made “Igmerald” in Germany from 1935 to 1942; and Carroll Chatham grew synthetic emerald in the United States from 1941 onward (Gems & Gemology, 2016).
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does it take to grow a lab emerald?
Months. GIA says flux crystal growth can take up to a year, and Union Carbide’s hydrothermal patent reports about 0.1 mm of growth a day. Flame fusion, the method used for lab sapphire and ruby, is the least expensive way to grow a gem (GIA).
Why is lab emerald more expensive than lab sapphire?
Because the methods are slow and costly: GIA says flux growth needs significant investment and very expensive equipment, and hydrothermal growth is slow and expensive, while flame fusion is the least expensive way to make lab sapphire and ruby.
Sources
- GIA: An introduction to synthetic gem materials (flux and hydrothermal emerald; hydrothermal emerald for jewelry from 1960)
- Google Patents: US 4,218,282, Method of preparation of chrysoberyl and beryl single crystals (beryl is an incongruent melting material)
- Google Patents: US 3,567,642, Union Carbide hydrothermal process for growing beryl (425 to 800 C, 7,000 to 30,000 psi, 0.1 mm a day)
- GIA, Gems & Gemology: Synthetic emeralds grown by Richard Nacken in the mid-1920s (Winter 2016)
- GIA, Gems & Gemology: Chinese hydrothermal synthetic emerald (Schmetzer et al., Winter 1997)
- International Gem Society: Emerald value, price and jewelry information (flux and hydrothermal synthetic properties)
- Wikipedia: Emerald (Gilson since 1964; Linde 1965 to 1970; Tairus)
Keep reading
Amazon links are affiliate links (tag thegemtray-20): buying through them costs you nothing extra and supports the site. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.